Best Indestructible Dog Chew Toys for Aggressive Chewers
By Steve Holloway | Updated February 21, 2022
We may receive a small commission if you make a purchase from this page at no extra cost to you.
If you have an aggressive chewer, you know how hard it can be to find a dog toy that your dog likes, and that is durable enough to withstand their powerful chewing. The best dog chew toys should be fun, durable, safe, and come from reputable manufacturers to ensure that it'll last for more than a day or two.
It can be confusing to try and pick out the best toy, though, and this is why we did the research for you and rounded up the five best picks available. Before we get to the reviews, we've outlined everything you want to know about aggressive chewing toys in our buyer's guide below.
In a Hurry? Here's our Top 5 Picks at a Glance
Benebone Real Flavor Wishbone Dog Chew Toy at Chewy
"This chew toy features a slightly curved designed with a raised center and slightly larger ends that help your dog get a good grip on the top each time they lay down to chew it."
Nylabone Dura Chew Power Chew Dog Toy at Chewy
"Each toy comes infused with a flavor medley that will attract your dog for the taste and smell, but it's not overpowering enough to bother you if they leave it by you."
Pet Parents Gnawtlers Elk Antlers at Chewy
"The chew toy doesn't carry and odor, and it also doesn't get slimy when your dog chews on it to help prevent messes."
Kong Goodie Bone at Chewy
"Kong's Goodie Bone comes in small, medium, and large sizes with the option to buy two bones at once, and you can use it as both a chew toy and a fetch toy without any effort."
HuggleHounds Plush Corduroy Durable Squeaky Knottie Dog Toy at Chewy
"This toy is easy to clean, and you can simply toss it into the washing machine and tumble dry between play sessions to keep it looking and smelling great."
Who Would Benefit From a Chew Toy?
Technically, anyone that has a dog could benefit from getting them a chew toy because it'll help stop them from chewing on your items or engaging in destructive chewing. They're especially helpful if your dog is younger because you may not have had time to train them yet.
Another reason you'd get your dog a lot of chewing toys is to keep them stimulated if you have to work and leave them on their own. Having a few chew toys scattered around lets your dog choose which ones they play with, and it can help to keep them out of your things when you're not there to supervise them.
How to Curb or Stop Unwanted Chewing
You want to train your dog from as soon as you bring them home what is and what isn't acceptable for them to chew on. The first thing you want to do is take responsibility for your own belongings and make sure they're not in your dog's reach. Also, practice shutting your bedroom doors if you don't want your dog in there.
You may want to start and crate train your dog right away, so they're not roaming free when you're not home. You want to be able to supervise them at all times when you first bring them home, and crate training can really help with this goal.
Set aside an hour or two each day to interact with and stimulate your dog to help wear them out when they're home. You could take them to a dog park, take them on a walk or run, or just play with their toys with them. Once you wear them out, they shouldn't be so prone to chew and be destructive.
Buying Considerations
When it comes to your chew toys for your dogs, there are several important factors that you want to keep in mind when you shop for them. This can help ensure that you get a safe and durable toy that will last your dog through multiple chewing sessions.
Size
Your dog's toy size is very important because you want to get a toy that isn't too heavy or awkward for your dog to pick up, carry around, and enjoy. Most dog toys will go by your dog's weight with three or four broad categories, and you can pick the one that'll suit your dog's size when they're grown. This way, it'll also handle how powerful they can chew.
Material
One of the first things you'll notice is that you have a host of materials available for your dog toys like nylon, rubber, wood composite, fabrics, rope, and more. It may take a little trial and error before you find one that is durable enough to withstand your dog's chewing and one they like to play with.
Durability
One of the most important factors to consider is the durability of your chosen toy because your dog will put a lot of strain and pressure on it as they chew it. You want double stitching, reinforced seams, a nylon-type fabric, and you may even look for a rope body of stuffing so your dog can't simply tear it apart.
Stimulating
You want to stimulate your dog both mentally and physically when they play, and you don't have to sacrifice durability for functionality. Look for toys that allow you to slip treats inside that make your dog work to remove them, or find toys that you can hide and make your dog look for them.
Non-Toxic
If your dog accidentally swallows a piece of their toy, you want it to be a non-toxic material that simply passes through your dog's system without a problem. You can check the components of the toy and check to see if it's in the Archived Pet Supply Database. If it is, you shouldn't give the toy to your dog.
Our Top 5 Picks for the Best Dog Chew Toys for Heavy Chewers
1. Benebone Real Flavor Wishbone Dog Chew Toy
First up on our list of best toys for aggressive chewers is by Benebone, and you get the choice of purchasing a chicken, beef, or peanut-flavored chew for your dog. It comes in a small, medium, and large size to fit a variety of dogs, and it ensures that you'll find a size suitable for your pet.
This chew toy features a slightly curved designed with a raised center and slightly larger ends that help your dog get a good grip on the top each time they lay down to chew it. Each of these chew toys come made in the United States, and this can help reassure you of their high-quality ingredients and design.
The Benebone toy comes with 100% real bacon, chicken, or peanut flavor and scents that can help to entice your dog to chew on it and come back time and time again for more. Also, Benebone will make a donation to a host of animal shelters each time you buy one, so you're helping dogs in need simply by shopping.
This chew toy also has been featured on our top 10 dog toy list, check it out here.
What Other Dog Parents Thought About This Toy...
Dog parents who bought this chew toy for their dog liked that it had a slightly bent design with weighted ends that made it easier for their dogs to grip. Dog parents did mention that once it came apart, it tended to crumble rather quickly.
Things We Liked
- Available in several sizes
- Comes in three different flavor profiles
- Made in the US to strict quality standards
Things We Didn't Like
- Can break down quickly
- May not be small enough for tiny dogs
- Can get slimy after a few chew sessions
2. Nylabone Dura Chew Power Chew Dog Toy
The Dura Chew Power Chew Toy by Nylabone comes in a smooth ring, textured ring, textured bone, S bone, axis bone, and a variety pack that lets you pick your dog's favorite. The durable nylon material comes intended to survive extremely aggressive chewers over extended time without breaking down or falling apart.
This toy is very easy to clean between playtime, and all you have to do is wash it in warm and soapy water before drying it off with a towel and giving it back to your dog. The textured design helps to fight tartar and plaque buildup on your dog's teeth to keep their gums and teeth healthy.
Each toy comes infused with a flavor medley that will attract your dog for the taste and smell, but it's not overpowering enough to bother you if they leave it by you. This is also a relatively inexpensive chew toy at just over $5, and this means that you can easily purchase two or three.
What Other Dog Parents Thought About This Toy...
People who bought Nylabone's extreme chewer toy for their dog liked that they had several shapes available as well as the choice of textured or non-textured. They did say that it doesn't come in more than one size, and it may be too heavy for smaller dog breeds.
Things We Liked
- Available in textured and non-textured designs
- Comes in several shapes
- Features flavor medley infused into the bone
Things We Didn't Like
- Only comes in one size
- May not have a strong enough flavor to entice picky dogs
- Might break down quickly with larger dogs
3. Pet Parents Gnawtlers - Premium Elk Antlers for Dogs
This chew toy comes made from premium Elk antlers that have a high amount of calcium, manganese, zinc, and more to give your dog a nutrient boost each time they chew on them. You can choose from four different sizes that allows you to quickly and easily tailor your selection to your dog's size and weight.
This all-natural chew toy doesn't leave any residue behind when your dog chews on it, and this makes it great for both indoor and outdoor use. The elk antler piece comes vacuumed sealed to help protect it from miscellaneous contaminants and keep your dog healthy when they eat it.
The chew toy doesn't carry and odor, and it also doesn't get slimy when your dog chews on it to help prevent messes. You're able to boil the elkhorn in beef or chicken broth to make it more fragrant and interesting to your dog if they don't pick it up straight away without weakening it.
What Other Dog Parents Thought About This Toy...
People who bought this chew toy for their dog liked that it didn't leave a residue on the carpet or furniture when their dog chewed on it for extended sessions. Dog parents did say that this chew toy was slightly smaller than other options, even the large size.
Things We Liked
- Available in four sizes
- Doesn't leave a residue when your dog chews on it
- Comes packed with vitamins and nutrients
Things We Didn't Like
- Slightly more expensive for a smaller toy
- Can splinter apart and have jagged edges
- May be too thin for larger dogs
4. Kong Goodie Bone
Kong's Goodie Bone comes in small, medium, and large sizes with the option to buy two bones at once, and you can use it as both a chew toy and a fetch toy without any effort. The ends of the chew toy are hollow, and this allows you to insert treats to give your dog hours of fun as they try tog et them out.
You'll get a bright red coloring that makes this bone very easy to see both inside and outside, and it also makes it very difficult to lose it if your dog drops it while they're out and about. The thick nylon material can help to clean your dog's teeth and keep their gums healthy each time they use it.
Kong's products come made in the United States with globally-sourced materials that ensure you're getting a quality product each time you buy it. Finally, this bone is relatively inexpensive, and this means that you can replace it as you need without breaking your budget.
What Other Dog Parents Thought About This Toy...
People who purchased this product for their dog liked that they could stick treats into both ends of the toy to keep their dog entertained for hours on end. However, the ends of the toy do tend to be less durable than the body of the toy because they're hollow.
Things We Liked
- Available in a few different sizes
- Comes from globally-sourced and trusted materials
- Allows you to stuff treats in the ends
Things We Didn't Like
- Ends are slightly less durable
- Slightly heavier for smaller dogs
- Pieces can tear off and present a problem for your dog's digestive system
5. HuggleHounds Plush Corduroy Squeaky Knottie Dog Toy
This adorable, plush, and durable toy for aggressive chewers features 25 different character choices that you can mix and match, and you get two different size options. HuggleHounds' toy comes with tightly knotted limbs that give your dog a lot of texture to play with and chew on.
Your dog will have fun locating the numerous squeakers that are all over the body and limbs of this toy, and it comes with durable double stitching to help prevent your dog from shredding it. The body of this chew toy has a Tuffut Technology lining that enhances the toy's durability and makes it difficult to break.
This toy is easy to clean, and you can simply toss it into the washing machine and tumble dry between play sessions to keep it looking and smelling great. Additionally, the plush corduroy fabric is soft enough for your dog to snuggle and sleep with when they wear themselves out.
What Other Dog Parents Thought About This Toy...
People that bought HuggleHounds' chew toy for their dog were happy that it came with Tuffut Technology to enhance the toy's durability without sacrificing comfort. Dog parents did say that the larger toys could benefit from a few more knots along the toy's extremities.
Things We Liked
- Comes in 25 different character choices
- Has extra durable layer to ensure it lasts longer
- Very easy to clean
Things We Didn't Like
- May need more knots in the extremities
- Has a plastic loop that can tear the seam out
- Only comes in two sizes
Our Top Dog Toy Pick for Heavy Chewers
Our pick for the best toy for aggressive chewers is the Benebone Real Flavor Wishbone Dog Chew Toy because it comes in three different flavor combinations made with real ingredients to attract your dog. It also comes in four sizes to fit several different breed types without an issue.
The curved design was another point that drew us to this chew toy because it made it very easy for the dogs to pick up, balance, and chew. Finally, we liked that Benebone gave a percentage of every sale to animal shelters around the United States.